Banana Ice Cream

I have something SO awesome to share with you, I can hardly stand it!

I can take NO credit whatsoever for this delicious concoction.

Most of my recipes are my own creations, or such a major overhaul of someone else’s idea that I can still claim it as my own.

This, however, is strictly the brilliance of Use Real Butter.  And even then, credit is given to  Apartment Therapy’s The Kitchn.  And THAT author gives credit to her sister!

So, to Apartment Therapy’s Sister, I humbly bow and give great thanks and Squee’s!  (And terrific thanks to the other site’s for sharing this amazingness-in-a-bowl!)

WHAT is so worthy of such lavish praise, you wonder?


Not banana flavored  ice cream, but actual ice cream made out of bananas!  I know, right?!

What are you to do for ice cream when your child can have NO milk, NO eggs, and NO coconut?? (Because coconut milk ice cream was my answer to the ice cream question until we learned about his Fructose Malabsorption.)  Oh, and how are you to sweeten it when your child can’t have Fructose?

I basically had decided my poor sweetie would just have to do without ice cream from here on out.  Sad, but necessary.

No more!  I will feed him this ice cream for breakfast, lunch, dinner, and snacks, too, if he wants it.  It could NOT be healthier or better for him.  And it’s dairy-free, egg-free, and SUGAR-FREE!!!

So here’s what you do:

Grab 4 bananas, peel them and slice them up. Lay the slices on a cookie sheet and put it in your freezer for at least an hour.


Bananas sliced and already frozen

Bananas sliced and already frozen

Take the frozen banana slices and toss them in your food processor.

Frozen banana slices in my food processor

Frozen banana slices in my food processor

Put the lid on and let ‘er rip!  At first, the bananas turn sort of sand or grain-like…they look sort of like pellets, actually.

Not the best picture, but you can get the idea of the pellet look of the frozen bananas

Not the best picture, but you can get the idea of the pellet look of the frozen bananas

At this point, you have to start the process of taking off the lid, scraping down the sides, processing a little more, repeat un-til…it looks like this:

Would you look at that: Banana Ice Cream!

Would you look at that: Banana Ice Cream!

By this point, both the Geek and Mr. Charm were severely invading my personal space to see what I was making, so I took pity and gave them each a lick off the spoon.  They both got wide eyes, went “Yum!” and begged for more.

But I held firm: I knew we weren’t done yet!

Into the food processor went two additional ingredients: peanut butter and cocoa powder!  (Though, you could just eat it without adding a single thing to it – it’s that good!  And without the peanut butter, it would be top 8 allergy-free.)

1 TBS each of peanut butter and cocoa powder, ready to blend

1 TBS each of peanut butter and cocoa powder, ready to blend

I let it blend some more, scraped the sides once for good measure, and dumped it all into a glass dish.  The blogs I read for this recipe said it could actually be scooped  if you put it back into the freezer, and I was SO looking forward to making a pretty, scooped bowl of ice cream for my boys that I wasn’t willing to let them eat it soft-serve – though, of course, that is a viable option!

(Those of you who have experimented with alternative ice cream recipes can verify: it’s hard to make pretty scoops out of most ice creams made in non-traditional ways.  So this was exciting for me!)

In the glass pan, ready to re-freeze

In the glass pan, ready to re-freeze

Alas, we sat down to dinner not long after this picture was taken, and at the promise of banana ice cream for dinner both the Geek and Mr. Charm freaking inhaled  their dinner!  We’re talking “clean-your-plate” wolfing, here (which isn’t so strange for the Geek, but is mind-blowing for Mr. Charm!).

So, ready for dessert, I went to scoop their bowls and…yep.  It hadn’t frozen up yet.  Soft serve ice cream it was!

Impatient men.  Had to eat it soft-serve.

Impatient men. Had to eat it soft-serve.

Both boys loved their ice cream.  They ate their entire bowls and probably would have eaten more, if I wasn’t being mean and hiding it in the freezer to see if it really DOES scoop once frozen.  (He he he.)

The Geek’s valued opinion of this dessert:  He liked the plain banana better than the peanut butter and cocoa version, though he thinks he will love it with just cocoa added.  He said the texture was just as good as traditional, store-bought (full of poison) ice cream – and even liked it better than the coconut milk ice creams I had made for Mr. Charm that *I* thought were better than any store bought ice cream I had ever tried!

So, banana has been moved up the list on Mr. Happy’s food trial list.  Mama would sure  like to have a dessert, these days!

Later on, I went back to the ice cream to see if it scooped.


The Best Looking Homemade Ice Cream I've Ever Made

The Best Looking Homemade Ice Cream I’ve Ever Made

So, knowing that it does really well in the freezer, I plan to make up multiple batches of this at once and store it in the freezer so we can finally be like normal people and just have ice cream on hand whenever one of us gets a yen for it.  <happy dance!>

By the way, you could add anything you want to this: chocolate chips, nuts, fruit puree’s, you name it.  Get creative and make something delicious!


BANANA ICE CREAM (one, two or three ingredients)

– 4 bananas, very ripe
– 1 TBS peanut butter (optional)
– 1 TBS cocoa powder (optional)
– any other add-ins: chocolate chips, nuts, fruit, etc.

  1. Peel and slice the bananas, and freeze the slices on a cookie sheet for one hour minimum.
  2. Toss the frozen slices into a food processor, and process until creamy.  (That’s it, if you want plain banana ice cream!  If you want other flavors, continue:)
  3. Add your optional ingredients to the food processor, and process until well mixed.
  4. Serve it up soft serve, or place back into the freezer to make pretty scoops.
  5. Enjoy the healthiest dessert you’ll ever eat!


Would you ever imagine bananas would cream up like this?  What would you add-in to your banana ice cream?


This post was shared with Allergy Free WednesdaysWhole Foods Wednesdays, and Real Food Wednesdays.

Tagged , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

10 Responses to Banana Ice Cream

  1. Pingback: Allergy-Free Wednesdays: February 27, 2013 | The Willing Cook

  2. Pingback: Chocolate (Avocado/Banana) Pudding – with an “Instant Pudding” Option! - Cradle Rocking Mama

  3. Jeshyr says:

    Oh this is fantastic! I knew when I was a kid we sometimes made ice poles by sticking sticks into half a banana and freezing that – they are surprisingly edible and soft compared to “most” frozen fruit even without any blending at all!

    Your kitchen creativity in the face of unbelievably limited options is really impressive, y’know? I might have to try some of these myself!

    • Mama says:

      Thanks! I’ve never just eaten frozen bananas, myself, but I may have to make those for Jed this summer. Sort of the “lazy” banana ice cream for summer, you think? 🙂 Thanks for the idea!

      • Jeshyr says:

        You probably already know this, but it just occured to me while I was resting today that you might not because most people don’t eat a ton of frozen stuff – Are you familiar with eating other frozen things? Small things – or things that can come in small pieces – are almost always good frozen! I am very odd and actually like eating still-frozen frozen *peas* in summer, but some that are more ordinary include frozen raspberries, blueberries, halved strawberries, etc.

        Pretty much any fruit that’s small enough to be still bite-able when frozen can be good to eat frozen – if it’s too big then you can slice or cut it before freezing, as long as you put it in something airtight soon after it’s frozen. I can’t remember your safe list but I recall as a kid eating frozen slices of oranges and kiwifruit at least. I’m sure with your creativity you could come up with an endless list 🙂

        (BTW if you haven’t connected, I’m the ‘Ricky Buchanan’ from Facebook :))

  4. Pingback: Coconut Milk Vanilla Ice Cream with Homemade Magic Shell Topping - Cradle Rocking Mama

  5. Pingback: Banana Goat Milk Ice Cream - Cradle Rocking Mama

  6. Tina says:

    We love this at our house! We started with just banana, but as we trialled new foods we’ve done it with watermelon, grapes, and spinach…and all those together!

    • Carrie says:

      Zac loves sweet potato ice cream, which is just banana and sweet potato mixed. It was also the only way I could ever get him to eat apricots. Haven’t considered putting a green veggie into it, but…why not? Good idea!

Comments are love! Tell me what you're thinking!